Methodology
How we check products
Every product shows five tiles: Safety, Quality, Company, Ethics and Privacy. Each one shows its most important current fact. Tap a tile to see every fact behind it, with its source and date. The tiles are information for you: only a recall can take a product off this site. Under the tiles, each product also says where it’s made, when the maker says so.
What the marks mean
- Serious issue. Reserved for a short list of official findings: a company on the U.S. forced-labor entity list, or a U.S. government (CISA) instruction to stop using a device.
- Worth knowing. For example, a recall that covers some units only, a government action against the maker in the last 5 years, or a device that needs the maker’s cloud.
- Credential. A named, checkable certification, such as ENERGY STAR, NSF or USP testing for supplements, or FDA clearance for a medical device. A credential never hides a concern.
- Nothing found. We checked the sources named in the tile, on the date shown. It means nothing turned up there, not a guarantee.
- Not reviewed yet. We haven’t checked this yet. It is not a good or a bad sign.
- Does not apply. For example, Privacy for a product with no app, account or connection.
The tiles never use colour alone: each one also has a shape and a word.
Safety
Recalls from the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) for every product. Also, from NHTSA for car seats and tires, and from the FDA for pet food, coffee and health and beauty products. Plus FDA and EPA notices and safe-sleep guidance where they apply. A product that matches a recall of all units is removed. A recall that covers only some units, lots or sizes is shown with the exact scope. Search the recall data yourself.
Quality
Every product here was picked by a person, for the reasons written under “Why we picked it”. When an independent body has checked the product, we name it: NSF or USP testing for supplements, FDA clearance for medical devices, independent accuracy validation for blood-pressure monitors, or NHTSA’s Ease-of-Use rating for car seats (how easy a seat is to use correctly, not crash protection).
Company
Who makes the product and who owns that company, from public records such as Wikidata (CC0) and company filings. Final government actions against the maker: FTC cases and orders, CPSC civil penalties (often for reporting a hazard late), NHTSA consent orders, state attorney-general settlements, and DOJ, SEC or FCC actions. We also show data-breach notices filed with the Washington and California attorneys general.
A breach notice means the company filed a notice. We don’t show lawsuits or allegations, only final actions and official filings. Actions from more than 5 years ago, or against a parent company or a previous owner, aren’t shown on product pages. Every automatic match between a record and a brand is checked by a person before it appears. We link to each maker’s Better Business Bureau profile, but don’t show BBB ratings.
Where it’s made
“Where it’s made” comes only from the maker’s own statements, its manuals or packaging, or government records (like EPA pesticide labels or CPSC recall notices). “Designed in” and a company’s home country don’t count: a company headquartered in one country often has its products made in another. When the maker doesn’t say, we say so (“Not stated by the maker”). Makers move production, so we recheck every month and show the date we last checked.
The “Where it’s made” filter on each shelf uses the same facts. A product the maker says is made in several countries appears under each of them. Products whose maker doesn’t say are left out while a country is selected. The same facts make up our picks by country pages.
Ethics
Whether the maker, or its parent company, is on the U.S. Department of Homeland Security’s UFLPA Entity List. Goods from companies on that list are presumed to be made with forced labor and are barred from U.S. import. DHS says the list is not exhaustive, so “not on the list” is all we claim. We also show certifications checked in the certifier’s own directory: ENERGY STAR (matched by exact model number), USDA Organic, Fair Trade, Rainforest Alliance, Leaping Bunny, OEKO-TEX and B Corp.
Privacy and security
For connected products: whether it works without the internet, needs a maker account or a subscription, and the maker’s published security-update period. We also show actively exploited vulnerabilities from the U.S. Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) and FTC privacy actions. Where an open-source firmware project supports a device, we say so (Second Life).
What we never do
- Sell placements, or let a store or brand pay to change a tile.
- Repeat health claims. We state facts such as “FDA-cleared” or “USP Verified”, not what a product is said to do for you.
- Show scores or ratings from other review publications or the BBB.
- Turn an unconfirmed automatic match into a public claim about a company.
- Treat “designed in”, a company’s home country or a store listing as where a product is made.
Spotted a mistake? Email shopping@openpublic.com and we’ll check it.