A winter tire is defined by a test result moulded onto its sidewall, and it is recalled by production week and size. So we pick tire lines, check every line against federal tire recalls, and tell you what to read on the tire itself.
What the markings mean
The three-peak mountain snowflake (3PMSF or “Alpine” symbol). Transport Canada explains that manufacturers may show this symbol on tires that meet a snow-traction requirement. The tire is tested on medium-packed snow and must score a traction index of at least 110, meaning at least 10% better than a reference test tire. It’s a snow test only. In a 2019 briefing, Transport Canada said Canada and the United States have no minimum government standard for grip on ice.
The DOT code and its date. Under U.S. rules (49 CFR 574.5), the final group of a tire’s identification number is a four-digit date code: the first two digits are the week of manufacture and the last two are the year. “0109” means the first full week of 2009. You need this number to tell whether a tire is covered by a recall.
Registration. The U.S. Tire Manufacturers Association says to register new tires, so that “manufacturers can contact you in the event of a recall.” You register with the tire’s DOT tire identification number, which starts with the letters “DOT”.
The rules we apply
- We pick tire lines, not sizes. Sizes, load and speed ratings, and warranties vary across a line. Our listing covers the line, and you pick the size at the store.
- Every line is checked against NHTSA tire recalls. We download the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s (NHTSA) recall files and match each tire line by brand and line name. We tell similar names apart. For example, NHTSA campaign 25T003000 covers the Bridgestone Blizzak 6, a different line from the Blizzak WS90, so it isn’t matched to the WS90.
- Recalls limited to sizes or weeks are shown, not hidden. In the NHTSA data we use, tire recalls are often limited to particular sizes and a range of production weeks. You can check both on the sidewall before you buy, so we still list the line but show the recall with its exact sizes and weeks. A listed line with a recall never shows “no matching recalls.” If a recall gives no size or week limits, we hide the line until we’ve read the notice.
- Fresh data or nothing. Our tire pages appear only while our NHTSA tire recall data is less than 14 days old.
- Tests named, sellers named. We cite test results with their source. When the tester is also a retailer, such as Tire Rack, we say so. We don’t use Amazon for tires, because most tire listings there are from third-party sellers.
- Studdable tires. We say when a tire can take optional studs, and remind you that stud rules and seasons are set by each state.
- New models wait for an independent test. When a maker launches a new winter tire, we wait for an independent test before adding it. Maker-run comparisons don’t count.
What we have turned down
No winter tire is on our “Didn’t make the cut” list yet. The recall rule above means a line with an unlimited recall would be hidden until we review the notice.
What we can’t check, and you should
- The DOT date code on the tires you get. Ask the store for the date codes before fitting, or read them on the sidewall. Compare them with any recall shown on our page.
- Size and ratings for your car. Use the size, load index and speed rating on your vehicle’s door-jamb placard or in the owner’s manual.
- A full set. Transport Canada advises fitting winter tires in sets of four.
- Tread depth. Transport Canada advises against using winter tires with less than 4 mm (5/32 inch) of tread.
- Registration. Register the tires with the maker after fitting, using their DOT numbers.
- Studs. Check your state’s rules and dates before buying studs.
Questions people ask
Is an “M+S” tire a winter tire? M+S (mud and snow) is a different marking. The snow-traction test behind the three-peak mountain snowflake is the one Transport Canada describes for winter tires, so that is the symbol we look for in this category.
Does the snowflake symbol mean a tire grips on ice? No. It is a snow-traction test. In 2019 Transport Canada said there was no government minimum standard for ice grip in Canada or the U.S.
When do winter tires help? Transport Canada says all-season and summer tires start to lose grip below 7°C (about 45°F), because their rubber becomes less elastic.
How do I read a tire’s age? Find the last four digits of the DOT code. For example, “2324” means the 23rd week of 2024.
What if my size is in a recall shown on your page? Check whether your tires’ DOT week falls in the recalled range. If it does, contact the tire maker or a dealer about the remedy described in the recall notice.