Supplements are the category where we say the least, on purpose. We don’t tell you what a supplement will do for you, and we don’t suggest doses. What we can tell you is whether an independent certifier lists the exact product, and whether the product or its maker has a recall or a government action on record.
How supplements are regulated
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) says it “does NOT have the authority to approve dietary supplements for safety and effectiveness” before they are sold. Makers and distributors are responsible for making sure their products meet the safety standards. The FDA can take action against a product after it is on the market, for example if it is unsafe or mislabelled. The FDA also generally doesn’t approve supplement claims or labels before they are used.
Two things the rules do require:
- Good manufacturing practice. Companies that make, package or hold supplements must follow current good manufacturing practices, which help ensure identity, purity, quality, strength and composition.
- A disclaimer on structure/function claims. A label that says what a supplement does to the body must carry the statement “This statement has not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration,” and say the product is not intended to “diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.”
Words like “standardized,” “verified” or “certified” on a label don’t necessarily guarantee quality, the National Institutes of Health’s complementary health center (NCCIH) said in 2019.
The certification we require
NSF/ANSI 173 is NSF International’s standard for dietary supplements. NSF publishes a directory of certified products, with a date showing when it was last updated. NSF asks anyone relying on a listing to contact NSF to confirm its status.
The rules we apply
- Certified in the directory, or not listed. We list a supplement only if we found that exact product in NSF’s dietary supplement directory, or it carries the USP Verified mark and we confirmed it with USP. A certification claimed on the bottle or the seller’s page isn’t enough. We record the directory entry and the date we checked. USP’s directory blocked our automated checks, so none of our current listings relies on USP.
- “NSF-certified,” said carefully. NSF also runs a sport program. Unless the brand’s own page states that a product is Certified for Sport, we say “NSF-certified (NSF/ANSI 173)” and nothing more.
- No health claims. We describe what a product contains, its form and serving size, and its certification. We don’t repeat what it is said to do for you, even when the label says it.
- Staples only, for now. This section lists simple staples: single vitamins and minerals (and simple pairings such as D3 with K2), fish oil, creatine, protein powder, electrolyte capsules, and standard and prenatal multivitamins. We leave out blends that combine many vitamins, plant extracts and probiotics in one product, even certified ones.
- Recalls and enforcement. We check recalls and enforcement reports by brand. Where a brand has had a recall, we say which product it covered. Some brands with recalls on record were not picked. We also check for FDA warning letters to the brand.
- No network-marketing sellers. We don’t list products sold mainly through independent distributors.
Products we turned down
From our public “Didn’t make the cut” list, with the reasons as we published them:
- LMNT Recharge Electrolyte Drink Mix. “As of 2026-11-14, LMNT drink mixes are not listed in NSF’s dietary-supplement certification directory, and we found no USP Verified mark for them; we list only supplements certified by NSF or USP.”
- Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier. “As of 2026-11-14, Liquid I.V. Hydration Multiplier is not listed in NSF’s dietary-supplement certification directory, and we found no USP Verified mark for it; we list only supplements certified by NSF or USP.”
- AG1 Next Gen. “AG1 is listed in NSF’s dietary-supplement certification directory, but it combines dozens of vitamins, minerals, plant extracts and probiotics in one powder; as of 2026-11-14 this section lists single-nutrient staples and standard multivitamins only.”
What we can’t check, and you should
- Whether it’s right for you. We give no medical or dosing advice. Ask your doctor or pharmacist, especially if you take medicines, are pregnant or are buying for a child.
- The product you receive. A certification covers specific products. Check that the name, form and size on the bottle match the directory listing.
- The seller. Buy from the brand, a big-box store or an authorized seller. Our offers favour these.
- Problems. If you have a bad reaction, you can report it to the FDA through its Safety Reporting Portal (linked from fda.gov/safety/report-problem-fda).
Questions people ask
Is a supplement with “FDA” on the label approved by the FDA? No. The FDA says it does not have the authority to approve dietary supplements for safety and effectiveness before they are sold.
What does NSF certification tell me? That NSF lists the product as certified to NSF/ANSI 173, its dietary-supplement standard. We show the listing and the date we checked it. We don’t present it as a claim about what the product does for your health.
Why isn’t my favourite brand here? Usually because we couldn’t find the product in a certifier’s directory, or it is a blend outside the staples we list. If you know of a listing we missed, email us and we’ll check it.