A smoke or carbon monoxide (CO) alarm has one job: to sound when it should and stay quiet when it shouldn’t. So we start with the safety standard it is built to, then look at what makes it practical to live with: its battery, its links to other alarms, its voice alerts and any app.
The standards
Smoke alarms: UL 217. The 8th edition of UL 217 took effect on June 30, 2024, according to the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). It changes two things:
- Alarms must respond well to both smoldering and flaming fires.
- For the first time there is a nuisance test: two hamburger patties are broiled 10 feet from the alarm, and it passes only if it stays quiet.
NIST says you can check the back of an alarm for a label stating that it meets UL 217. It also notes that older stock built before the new edition may still be on sale.
UL Standards & Engagement says the 2025 edition of the NFPA 72 fire alarm code requires smoke alarms installed within 20 feet of a fixed cooking appliance to be listed for nuisance resistance under the 8th edition of UL 217. That code applies only where a state or local government adopts and enforces it.
CO alarms: UL 2034. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) helped develop UL 2034, the safety standard for CO alarms, and advises buying an alarm that “meets the requirements of the current UL 2034 safety standard.” CPSC says more than 200 people in the U.S. die each year from accidental CO poisoning not related to fires and associated with consumer products.
Where they go. The U.S. Fire Administration (USFA) says to install smoke alarms:
- in and outside every bedroom and sleeping area
- on every level of the home, including the basement
- interconnected, so “when one sounds, they all sound”
CPSC says to put CO alarms on every level and outside sleeping areas, battery-powered or with battery backup, away from heating vents and places furniture or drapes could cover them. USFA recommends either both types of smoke alarm (ionization and photoelectric) or dual-sensor alarms.
The rules we apply
- The standard, and who says so. Where the maker states which UL 217 edition (smoke) and UL 2034 (CO) its alarm meets, we say so and label it as the maker’s statement; UL’s own directory needs a login, so we couldn’t confirm these there.
- Interconnection, stated plainly. We say whether an alarm links to others, how (wired, radio or Wi-Fi), and whether it links only to the same brand. If it can’t link at all, we say so and point to an interlinked option.
- Battery type. Where the maker states it, we say whether the battery is a sealed 10-year battery or a replaceable one.
- Connected alarms. For Wi-Fi alarms we say what depends on the maker’s app and cloud. We check the brand against CISA’s Known Exploited Vulnerabilities catalog.
- Recalls by model. Several alarm makers have had recalls of specific models or date codes. We list them by model and date range, and say whether any covers our pick.
- Current products. We don’t list an alarm its maker has stopped making.
What we have turned down
No smoke or CO alarm is on our “Didn’t make the cut” list yet.
What we can’t check, and you should
- Your local code. Fire codes such as NFPA 72 apply where a state or local government adopts them. Check what applies to your home before you choose between battery and hardwired models.
- The manufacture date. USFA says to replace alarms 10 years after the date they were made. Check the date on the back when you install one.
- Testing. USFA and CPSC say to test alarms monthly.
- Batteries. For alarms with replaceable batteries, replace them at least once a year (USFA says this for 9-volt models), or choose sealed 10-year batteries.
- CO sources. CPSC says a CO alarm “is no substitute for proper use and upkeep of appliances that can produce CO.” Have fuel-burning appliances serviced.
Questions people ask
Photoelectric, ionization or both? USFA recommends either both types or dual-sensor alarms. Under the 8th edition of UL 217, alarms must respond well to both smoldering and flaming fires. NIST says the 8th edition was designed so that all alarms detect both kinds of fire, to end the need to choose between the two types. USFA still recommends both types or dual-sensor alarms.
Will a new alarm stop going off when I cook? The 8th edition adds a nuisance test, and the alarm has to stay quiet. NIST notes it still found alarms that “beep for bacon,” so placement matters. The 2025 NFPA 72 code, as UL Standards & Engagement describes it, says alarms shouldn’t go within 10 feet of a fixed cooking appliance unless there is no other place, and NIST suggests at least 6 feet and ideally 20 feet.
Do I need a combination smoke and CO alarm? CPSC recommends a CO alarm on every level and outside sleeping areas. USFA recommends smoke alarms in every bedroom too. A combination unit can cover both where the locations overlap.
How long does an alarm last? USFA says to replace the whole alarm 10 years from its manufacture date.