A medical alert system is a help button that calls a monitoring center, sold as a device plus a monthly service. The device is the smaller part of the cost. What you’re really choosing is a service contract, so we start with the price and cancellation terms, then look at how the system connects and what independent testers found.
How the pricing works
Most medical alert services charge some mix of these:
- Equipment. Some companies charge a one-time equipment fee and some lend the equipment free while you subscribe. For example, AARP reports that Medical Guardian charges a one-time $149.95 equipment fee for its MGHome base, while Bay Alarm Medical lends its SOS Home base station free and asks for it back when you cancel.
- Monthly monitoring. The fee for the monitoring center. Medical Guardian, for example, lets you pay monthly, quarterly or yearly and says the longer terms save money.
- Fall detection. Usually an add-on. AARP’s testers say automatic fall detection usually costs about $5 to $10 a month extra.
- Activation and cancellation. Check these terms carefully: Medical Guardian’s pricing page says “We don’t charge activation or cancellation fees, and we never will,” while a footnote on the same page says “Cancellation fees may apply.”
- Trial periods. AARP found Bay Alarm Medical’s trial is 15 days, while most of the companies it tested offer 30.
“Free” offers by robocall. In 2021 the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) returned more than $1.8 million to people harmed by the Lifewatch robocall scheme. The FTC said it “bombarded consumers with at least a billion unsolicited robocalls to pitch supposedly ‘free’ medical alert systems,” that it was hard to cancel without paying a penalty, and that its messages falsely claimed endorsements from groups such as the American Heart Association.
In-home or mobile
- In-home systems have a base station in the home and a wearable button that works within range of it. The base connects over a cellular network or a landline. AARP measured an at-home range of about 1,000 feet for Bay Alarm Medical, and 1,300 to 1,400 feet for most of the others it tested.
- Mobile systems are a single wearable with its own cellular connection and GPS, so they work away from home too. AARP tested GPS by calling from a grocery store, a hardware store and an airport cell phone lot.
Monitoring centers
Pressing the button connects to a monitoring center staffed around the clock. Medical Guardian and MobileHelp say their monitoring centers are in the U.S., and Bay Alarm Medical says its centers are in Utah and Idaho. MobileHelp has been owned by Medical Guardian since 2024.
What fall detection can and can’t do
Automatic fall detection calls the monitoring center without the button being pressed. Bay Alarm Medical says its system triggers on a sudden downward movement followed immediately by a lack of movement. AARP’s testers ran four kinds of falls onto a mat, at least 12 falls per device, and counted 9 of 12 as a pass. AARP says fall detection “isn’t 100 percent accurate,” and quotes an occupational therapist calling it “a safety net, not a guarantee.”
The makers say the same:
- Medical Guardian: fall detection “does not work 100% of the time.”
- Bay Alarm Medical: “There’s no such thing as a 100% accurate auto fall detection system,” and “It should only be used as a backup plan and should not be relied on 100%.” It says to always press the button if you can.
- MobileHelp: “It may not detect every fall and may sometimes send a false alert,” and fall detection works only if it is part of your plan.
The rules we apply
- Published prices and terms only. We list a service only when its device price, monthly fee and cancellation terms are public. Each pick shows the full price, the fall-detection fee and how to cancel, with the date we checked.
- Conflicting terms, stated plainly. Where a company’s own pages disagree, we quote both and say to ask before signing up.
- Fall detection results from a named tester. We report AARP’s test results for each pick, and each maker’s own warning about fall detection. We don’t claim fall detection catches every fall.
- Ownership. When one brand owns another, we say so.
- No health claims. We describe what a service does and costs. We don’t say it prevents harm or makes anyone safer.
Products we turned down
From our public “Didn’t make the cut” list, with the reason as we published it:
- Life Alert Medical Alert Service. “Life Alert publishes no prices or contract terms on its website; it asks you to call or request a quote and brochure. We only list medical alert services whose device price, monthly fee and cancellation terms are public.”
What we can’t check, and you should
- The contract you’re offered. Prices and terms change, and phone offers can differ from the website. Ask for the total first-year cost, any cancellation fee and whether equipment must be returned, and get it in writing.
- Coverage where you live. A cellular system needs a signal in the home, and a mobile one where the wearer goes. Test it during the trial.
- The range in your home. Press the button from the farthest rooms, the bathroom and the yard during the trial.
- Fall detection for the wearer. Bay Alarm Medical says its fall detection should not be used by some people, including those with memory loss or seizures. Ask the company whether it suits the wearer.
- Regular tests. Ask the company how to run a test call, and do it regularly.
- Unexpected calls. As in the FTC’s Lifewatch case, be wary of an unexpected call offering a “free” system.
Questions people ask
Is a landline system cheaper? It can be. Bay Alarm Medical lists its landline in-home system at $27.95 a month, against $34.95 for its cellular version. A landline system needs a working landline in the home.
Do I need fall detection? That depends on the wearer, and we can’t judge it for you. All three makers of our picks say fall detection can miss falls, so the wearer should still press the button when they can.
Can I cancel any time? It depends on the company and plan. MobileHelp says its service is month-to-month and can be cancelled any time. Bay Alarm Medical says you can cancel any time and get unused months refunded, less shipping costs. Read the cancellation terms before you sign up.
Why don’t you list Life Alert? Because it doesn’t publish its prices or contract terms. We’ll look again if it does.