A first phone is two purchases: a device and a set of rules about what it can do. Some kid phones build the rules into the phone and the plan. Ordinary iPhones and Android phones have free parental controls built in. Either way, the controls that let a parent see more also mean more of a child’s data is collected. This guide sets out the facts on each, the rules we apply, and what only you can decide.
Children’s privacy law: COPPA basics
The Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA), enforced by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), gives parents control over personal information that companies collect online from children under 13. The FTC says:
- the rule covers operators of commercial sites and online services directed to children under 13, and general-audience operators that know they are collecting personal information from children under 13
- it covers mobile apps and connected devices
- covered companies must give parents notice and get their consent before collecting a child’s personal information, and must keep the information secure
- parents can review the information collected about their child, withdraw consent and have it deleted
- COPPA does not apply to teenagers
The FTC amended the COPPA Rule on April 22, 2025. If you think a company broke the rules, the FTC asks you to report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
The built-in controls
Apple (iPhone and iPad). Apple’s Screen Time includes parental controls, managed through Family Sharing. The child needs their own Apple Account in your Family Sharing group. Apple says parents can:
- restrict content, apps and settings
- set schedules for which apps the child can use at different times of day
- set time allowances for apps
- choose who the child can communicate with in Messages, FaceTime and Phone
- approve or decline purchases and downloads with Ask to Buy
Apple’s Communication Safety, on by default for children under 18 (age rules vary by region), uses on-device machine learning to spot sensitive photos and videos, then blurs them, warns the child and offers resources. Apple says detection happens on the device and Apple doesn’t receive an indication that sensitive content was detected.
Apple Watch For Your Kids (formerly Family Setup) lets a parent set up a cellular Apple Watch for a child who doesn’t have an iPhone. Apple lists a Series 4 or later, or SE or later, with cellular, and says a cellular plan isn’t needed for setup but is needed for some features. Parents choose the watch’s contacts, can turn on Schooltime, and can let the child share their location.
Google Family Link (Android). Google says parents can approve or block apps, set screen time limits and lock devices, filter sites in Chrome, see where the child is with their Android device, and manage who the child can call or text in some apps. Google also lists what parents can’t do, including:
- read the child’s emails or messages
- listen to their calls
- see past searches or Chrome browsing history
- see YouTube watch history
- view the child’s screen remotely
Children under 13 (or the age that applies in their country) must stay supervised. Older children can stop supervision, but Google says children under 18 need a parent’s approval to do so, and both will be notified.
What parents can see with our picks
| Phone | What parents see, per the maker | What the maker collects, per its privacy policy |
|---|---|---|
| Gabb Phone 4 | Location with Safe Zone alerts, approved contacts (if you turn on parent-managed contacts), call and text logs, alerts about texts flagged as harmful | The child’s location and the content of texts the child sends; says it doesn’t sell children’s data |
| Pinwheel Plus 6 | Approved contacts and apps, schedules, the child’s texts and call history | The child’s texts, images, call history and location; most activity history kept for 12 months, but account information including messages kept for the life of the account plus 60 days; says it doesn’t use children’s data for advertising |
| Bark Phone | Alerts with the concerning part of messages, not every message; location, app and website controls, screen-time schedules | Scans content with automated systems including AI; keeps identifiable data generally for 30 days (portions may be kept longer for reports); says it never sells data |
Plans and contracts
Kid phones are often tied to the maker’s own cellular plan:
- Gabb phones work only with Gabb’s plans. Gabb lists Standard plans at $34.99 a month without a contract, or $31.99 and $29.99 on 1- and 2-year contracts. Gabb says contract plans carry an early termination fee. When a contract ends, Gabb says service continues month to month at the no-contract rate, and “Your monthly rate may increase when your contract ends.”
- Pinwheel lets you keep your own carrier and pay $17.99 a month for its caregiver portal, or use Pinwheel Wireless at $29.99 a month, with no contract.
- Bark phones need a Bark plan, from $29 a month for talk and text up to $79 for unlimited data. Bark describes no contract and says you can switch plans any time.
The rules we apply
- Device and plan priced together. We show the phone price and the monthly cost, and say whether a contract or early termination fee applies.
- Monitoring and data, from the company’s own documents. For every pick we state what parents can see and what the company collects and keeps, from its own pages and privacy policy, with the date we read them.
- No promises about safety. We describe what the controls do. We don’t claim a phone or app will keep a child safe.
- Recalls and regulators. We check CPSC recalls and search for FTC actions and lawsuits against each company.
What we have turned down
No first phone is on our “Didn’t make the cut” list yet.
What we can’t check, and you should
- How much to see. More monitoring means more of your child’s messages and location stored by a company. Read the privacy policy and decide which features to turn on.
- Coverage where you live. Check that the plan’s network works at home and at school.
- Updates. Pinwheel doesn’t publish how long its phones get security updates. Ask any maker before you buy.
- The full cost. Add up activation fees, the phone, the monthly plan and any early termination fee for the contract length you choose.
- Your child’s accounts. Parental controls work on the accounts and apps you set up. Check them again when your child gets a new app or turns 13.
Questions people ask
Do I need a special kid phone, or can I use an ordinary smartphone? Either can work. iPhones and Android phones come with Apple’s Screen Time and Google’s Family Link. Kid phones such as Gabb and Pinwheel ship without social media apps and without a web browser (Pinwheel says none by default), and they control apps and contacts through the maker’s own service.
Can I read my child’s texts? It depends on the phone. Pinwheel says parents can read texts. Gabb shows text logs and flags harmful messages. Bark sends alerts with the concerning part rather than every message. Google says Family Link doesn’t let parents read a child’s messages.
What happens when my child turns 13? COPPA protections apply only to children under 13. With Google Family Link, a child over 13 (or the age that applies in their country) can stop supervision, but needs a parent’s approval while under 18.
Does COPPA cover the parental-control app itself? COPPA covers online services directed to children under 13, including apps and connected devices, and general-audience services that know they collect children’s personal information. Whether a specific service is covered is a legal question we don’t answer. Each pick’s privacy policy says what it collects.