A car seat is the one baby product with its own federal crash-test standard and its own federal recall system. This page explains what those rules cover, what we check on top of them, what makes us turn a seat down, and what only you can check.
What the federal rules cover
FMVSS No. 213 is the U.S. safety standard for child restraint systems, set by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). Two newer parts are now taking effect:
- FMVSS No. 213a (side impact). NHTSA added a side-impact test for seats meant for children up to 40 lb or 43.3 in tall. The sled test simulates a crash into the side of the car nearest the child, at a change in speed of about 19 mph. NHTSA chose that level because it covers 92% of near-side crashes involving restrained children aged 0 to 12. In September 2026, NHTSA moved the compliance date from June 30, 2025 to December 5, 2026.
- FMVSS No. 213b. This updates the test bench so it is more like a modern rear seat, and adds testing with a lap-and-shoulder belt (lap-belt-only testing continues until September 1, 2029). It applies to seats manufactured on or after December 5, 2026. Makers can comply early.
Every seat must carry a label reading “Manufactured in” with the month and year it was made, and must come with an owner registration form. A maker uses the form to contact you if the seat is recalled. Online registration was already allowed; in 2023 NHTSA relaxed the rules on the form’s content and format and let makers add a QR code that links to online registration, saying it made the changes to get more recalled seats fixed. Makers must keep registration records for at least six years from the date the seat was made.
What we check
- Recalls from two agencies. We check every seat against NHTSA’s child-seat recall campaigns, not just the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) data we use for other baby products. Car seats don’t appear on this site until our NHTSA data has synced at least once. That way a seat never shows “no matching recalls” based on CPSC data alone.
- Partial recalls. Some recalls cover only a range of build dates. We list a seat with a partial recall only if you can tell whether a unit is affected before you buy it. If an online buyer can’t see the build date or serial number until the seat arrives, we leave the seat out.
- Independent tests by name. In “Why we picked it” we name the source of each test result, for example BabyGearLab’s lab tests, IIHS booster ratings, or reviews written by certified child passenger safety technicians (CPSTs). We count NHTSA complaints from NHTSA’s own complaint files.
- NHTSA Ease-of-Use ratings, where we have them. This rating measures how easy a seat is to use correctly, not how well it protects in a crash. NHTSA rates only some seats, and it rates one specific model number. We show the rating only when NHTSA rated the exact model we list, so many of our entries have none.
- Newer versions. When a maker sells a version labelled as meeting the new standards, we link to that version.
Seats we turned down
These are from our public “Didn’t make the cut” list, with the reasons as we published them:
- Nuna RAVA Convertible Car Seat. “Nuna has replaced the RAVA with the RAVA Next, and retailers describe the original as discontinued. RAVA seats with a plastic harness adjuster button made from July 16, 2016 to October 25, 2023 are under NHTSA recall 24C002000 (November 2024) because debris can stop the adjuster from holding the harness tight, and owners have kept filing NHTSA complaints about harness slipping since, some after the recall remedy. Seats made after October 25, 2023 are not in the recall.”
- Doona+ Infant Car Seat & Stroller. “BabyGearLab ranked the Doona last of 16 infant car seats in its 2023 tests, and it still did in the roundup updated September 2026, with the lowest crash-test sub-score in that group, while praising its built-in wheels. Doona has since released the Doona X, which it says meets the newer FMVSS 213b standard. Doona seats are also a frequent target of counterfeits sold online. No NHTSA recall covers this model as of November 2026.”
What we can’t check, and you should
- The label on the seat you receive. Check the “Manufactured in” date and the model number against any recall notice. A product page can’t tell you which batch you’ll get.
- Registration. Fill in the registration card or register online the day the seat arrives. This is how the maker reaches you about a recall.
- The fit in your car. We can’t test a seat in your vehicle. Install it as the manual says, and consider having a certified child passenger safety technician check it.
- The seller. Our Doona entry notes that popular seats get counterfeited and sold online. Buy from the brand, a big-box store or an authorized seller. Our offers favour these.
- Weight and height limits. Some seats come in versions with different limits. Check the limits on the listing and on the seat’s label.
Questions people ask
Is a seat made before December 5, 2026 unsafe? Not by itself. The FMVSS 213a and 213b requirements apply to seats manufactured on or after that date, and makers were allowed to comply early. The “Manufactured in” label tells you when a seat was made.
Why don’t you show a government crash-safety score? The only NHTSA rating we show is Ease-of-Use, which is about using the seat correctly. Passing FMVSS No. 213 is a legal requirement for every seat, so we don’t treat it as a reason to pick one. When we cite crash-test results, they come from named independent testers.
My baby fell asleep in the car seat. Is that OK? The American Academy of Pediatrics says that if a baby falls asleep in a car seat, stroller, swing or carrier, you should move them to a firm sleep surface, on their back, as soon as possible.